Dry January: Does it Lead to a February Binge?
Published by Jon McKinnon on Monday, February 11, 2019
Each January millions of people take part in Alcohol Concern’s official ‘Dry January’ programme. It’s said that 4.2 million people participated in January 2019.
During this period, these people abstain from drinking alcohol. However, most of these people will return to drinking alcohol in February.
Does Dry January trigger a binge in February?
Alcohol Concern claims Dry January serves to ‘reset’ participants’ relationship with alcohol. However, we feel this claim is highly likely an inflated one given that most people who participate in Dry January will quickly return to their normal drinking habits.
It’s also possible that undergoing a Dry January could trigger a binge in February. This binge would serve to wipe-out most health gains secured by abstaining from alcohol in January.
Clinical studies involving rats and humans
Animal studies conducted on rats backs up the idea that abstaining from alcohol for one month is generally followed by over-compensating in subsequent months.
Rats were given alcohol for a long period of time then had all alcohol removed from their environment. When alcohol was subsequently re-introduced, the rats drank greater quantities of alcohol than before.
Another study generally failed to prove the same effect in humans when alcohol was removed from US army recruits during their initial training. When these same recruits were again permitted to drink alcohol following the completion of their training, they tended to either drink the same or less than their typical pre-training amounts.
However, heavier drinkers were likely to binge following this period of enforced abstinence.
It must be noted that both the rats and the army recruits were forced to give up alcohol. This is different to Dry January since all participants freely volunteer to give up alcohol for a one month period.
A study conducted by Alcohol Concern
A 2014 study conducted jointly between Alcohol Concern and the University of Sussex claimed undergoing Dry January did not lead to binge drinking in January.
Emily Robinson, a past director of Alcohol Concern said: “The long term effects of Dry January have previously been questioned, with people asking if a month booze-free would cause people to binge-drink once February comes around.”
She claims no such effect has been proven.
This claim does conflict with the study conducted on US army recruits which suggest the heaviest drinkers to start are the most likely to binge drink after a period of abstinence.
Another study conducted by Alcohol Concern via a survey found that 800 people who completed Dry January in 2018 were, on average, continuing to drink less alcohol in August 2018.
The survey found half those surveyed drank about the same amounts of alcohol after completing Dry January than they did before. 40% drank less alcohol and 10% greater quantities than they did before completing Dry January.
The survey found that this 10% who drank the most tended to people those who were unable to complete the entire Dry January period.
The survey also claims those who completed Dry January continued to have improved sleep and weight loss throughout the year.
Weaknesses of Alcohol Concern’s study
The key disadvantage of this survey is that the results are self-selecting and thus not entirely representative of people who completed Dry January.
Also, out of 2,800 who signed up to the August follow-up survey, only 800 submitted their answers. This high-drop out rate is concerning.
Men were more likely than women to drop out of the follow-up survey, as were those who were identified as ‘heavy drinkers’ by the information they submitted when initially apply to take part in Dry January.
It’s also submitted that those who took part in the August survey were likely to consist of the most dedicated people, and this level of dedication cannot be said to apply to the entire population of people who took part in Dry January.
The University of Sussex is planning to conduct research in the future that will be more representative of the general population who completed Dry January.
Sales of alcohol throughout the year
Tax revenue figure published by HM Revenue and Customs reveals a sharp increase in the amount of alcohol sold during December. The amount of alcohol sold in January falls sharply and the pre-December sales of alcohol do not restore until March.
Alcohol purchases from March to November remain relatively consistent:
We cannot deny the health benefits to be had by reducing alcohol intake. However, the health benefits to be had by embracing abstinence for only a single-month are questionable and the evidence for these benefits is scant.
Those most likely to make it through the entire month of January without drinking alcohol are likely to be the ones who drank the least in the first place.
Those who drink the most throughout the year are those who stand to gain the most by successfully completing Dry January.
What if you are alcohol dependent?
It must be stressed that Dry January is not suitable for those who are alcohol dependent. Undergoing a ‘DIY’ alcohol detox in this manner is positively dangerous. Instead, you will require the assistance of a dedicated alcohol detox and alcohol rehab clinic.
For more information, contact our free helpline today on 0800 088 66 86 and we shall signpost you to an alcohol rehab and alcohol detox clinic in your local area.
Published on: Monday, February 11, 2019